This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is PF_PDFbutton-01-scaled.png

Chairman Jason Smith

House Ways and Means Committee

1139 Longworth HOB

Washington D.C. 20515

November 7, 2023

Dear Chairman Smith, 

On behalf of Independent Women’s Voice, I write to applaud the House Ways and Means Committee on holding a hearing on “Ensuring that ‘Woke’ Doesn’t Leave Americans Broke” examining how Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) investing is leaving Americans financially worse off. 

Financial advisors overseeing 401(k) and related pension plans should be maximizing returns for their clients, not dabbling with funds that stray from this objective.

ESG funds tend to perform poorly compared to non-ESG funds. As IWF Center for Energy and Conservation Director Gabriella Hoffman noted, 152 million Americans will see their retirement funds, estimated to be valued at $10 trillion, jeopardized by ESG considerations.

Last year, savings accounts depreciated by 22.9%—from $126,100 on average in quarter three of 2021 to $97,200 in quarter three of 2022. That’s a loss of $34,000 in savings. Another estimate found savings depreciated $23,818 from January to December 2022, falling from $144,280 to $111,210. 

According to its own proponents, ESG has been deemed “beyond redemption.” An October 2023 Morning Consult poll found only 20% of investors report they have ESG funds. And a recent ESG Attitudes Survey from the Association of Investment Companies revealed private investors are souring on ESG funds—down from 66% in 2021 to 53% today.

IWV applauds the House Ways and Means Committee and its members for examining the true cost of ESG investing and its ruinous effects on Americans’ hard-earned savings.


Hadley Heath Manning 

Vice President for Policy 

Independent Women’s Voice